The Universe of Disco


Mon, 07 May 2018

Katara constructs finite projective planes

This weekend I got a very exciting text message from Katara:

I have a math question for you

Oh boy! I hope it's one I can answer.

Okay

there's this game called spot it where you have cards with 8 symbols on them like so

The back of the 'Spot It' box shows four white circular cards,
each with 8 little pictures on it. A red double-headed arrow between
the first two cards shows that both cards have a picture of a
ladybug.  Another arrow between the second and third cards shows that
both cards have a picture of a red heart.  The next arrow connects the
trees on cards 2 and 3, and a fourth arrow shows that cards 1 and 4
both have apurple cat.  Even though part of card 3 is cut off, we can
see that they share a pair of lips. Cards 2 and 4 both have a gray
padlock picture, even though there's no arrow pointing it out.

and the goal is to find the one matching symbol on your card and the one in the middle

how is it possible that given any pair of cards, there is exactly one matching symbol

Well, whatever my failings as a dad, this is one problem I can solve. I went a little of overboard in my reply:

You need a particular kind of structure called a projective plane.

They only exist for certain numbers of symbols

A simpler example has 7 cards with 3 symbols each.

One thing that's cool about it is that the symbols and the cards are "dual": say you give each round card a name. Then make up a new deck of square cards. There's one square card for each symbol. So there's a square"Ladybug" card. The Ladybug card has on it the names of the round cards that have the Ladybug. Now you can play Spot with the square cards instead of the round ones: each two square cards have exactly one name in common.

In a geometric plane any two points lie on exactly one common line and any two lines intersect in exactly one common point. This is a sort of finite model of that, with cards playing the role of lines and symbols playing the role of points. Or vice versa, it doesn't matter.

More than you wanted to know 😂

ah thank you, I'm pretty sure I understand, sorry for not responding, my phone was charging

I still couldn't shut up about the finite projective planes:

No problem! No response necessary.

It is known that all finite projective planes have n²+n+1 points for some n. So I guess the Spot deck has either 31, 57, or 73 cards and the same number of symbols. Is 57 correct?

Must be 57 because I see from your picture that each card has 8 symbols.

Katara was very patient:

I guess, I would like to talk about this some more when i get home if that's okay

Any time.

(The game costs $13.)

Anyway this evening I cut up some index cards, and found a bunch of stickers in a drawer, and made Katara a projective plane of order 3. This has 13 cards, each with 4 different stickers, and again, every two cards share exactly one sticker. She was very pleased and wanted to know how to make them herself.

Each set of cards has an order, which is a non-negative integer. Then there must be !!n^2 + n + 1!! cards, each with !!n+1!! stickers or symbols. When !!n!! is a prime power, you can use field theory to construct a set of cards from the structure of the (unique) field of order !!n!!.

Fields to projective planes

Order 2

I'll describe the procedure using the plane of order !!n=2!!, which is unusually simple. There will be !!2^2+2+1 = 7!! cards, each with !!3!! of the !!7!! symbols.

Here is the finite field of order 2, called !!GF(2)!!:

+ 0 1
0 0 1
1 1 0
× 0 1
0 0 0
1 0 1
  • The stickers correspond to ordered triples of elements of !!GF(2)!!, except that !!\langle 0,0,0\rangle!! is always omitted. So they are:

    $$\require{cancel}\begin{array}{cc} \cancel{\langle 0,0,0\rangle} & \langle 1,0,0\rangle \\ \langle 0,0,1\rangle & \langle 1,0,1\rangle \\ \langle 0,1,0\rangle & \langle 1,1,0\rangle \\ \langle 0,1,1\rangle & \langle 1,1,1\rangle \\ \end{array} $$

    Of course, you probably do not want to use these symbols exactly. You might decide that !!\langle 1,0,0\rangle!! is a sticker with a picture of a fish, and !!\langle 0,1,0\rangle!! is a sticker with a ladybug.

  • Each card will have !!n+1 = 3!! stickers. To generate a card, pick any two stickers that haven't appeared together before and put them on the card. Say these stickers correspond to the triples !!\langle a,b,c\rangle!! and !!\langle x,y,z\rangle!!. To find the triple for the third sticker on the card, just add the first two triples componentwise, obtaining !!\langle a+x,b+y,c+z\rangle!!. Remember that the addition must be done according to the !!GF(2)!! addition table above! So for example if a card has !!\langle 1,0,1\rangle!! and !!\langle 0,1,1\rangle!!, its third triple will be

    $$\begin{align} \langle 1,0,1 \rangle + \langle 0,1,1 \rangle & = \\ \langle 1+0,0+1,1+1 \rangle & = \\ \langle 1,1,0 \rangle \end{align} $$

    Observe that it doesn't matter which two triples you add; you always get the third one!

Okay, well, that was simple.

Larger order

After Katara did the order 2 case, which has 7 cards, each with 3 of the 7 kinds of stickers, she was ready to move on to something bigger. I had already done the order 3 deck so she decided to do order 4. This has !!4^2+4+1 = 21!! cards each with 5 of the 21 kinds of stickers. The arithmetic is more complicated too; it's !!GF(2^2)!! instead of !!GF(2)!!:

+ 0 1 2 3
0 0 1 2 3
1 1 0 3 2
2 2 3 0 1
3 3 2 1 0
× 0 1 2 3
0 0 0 0 0
1 0 1 2 3
2 0 2 3 1
3 0 3 1 2

When the order !!n!! is larger than 2, there is another wrinkle. There are !!4^3 = 64!! possible triples, and we are throwing away !!\langle 0,0,0\rangle!! as usual, so we have 63. But we need !!4^2+4+1 = 21!!, not !!63!!.

Each sticker is represented not by one triple, but by three. The triples !!\langle a,b,c\rangle, \langle 2a,2b,2c\rangle,!! and !!\langle 3a,3b,3c\rangle!! must be understood to represent the same sticker, all the multiplications being done according to the table above. Then each group of three triples corresponds to a sticker, and we have 21 as we wanted.

Each triple must have a leftmost non-zero entry, and in each group of three similar triples, there will be one where this leftmost non-zero entry is a !!1!!; we will take this as the canonical representative of its class, and it can wear a costume or a disguise that makes it appear to begin with a !!2!! or a !!3!!.

We might assign stickers to triples like this:

$$ \begin{array}{rl} \cancel{\langle 0,0,0\rangle} & \\ \langle 0,0,1 \rangle & \text{apple} \\ \hline \langle 0,1,0 \rangle & \text{bicycle} \\ \langle 0,1,1 \rangle & \text{carrot} \\ \langle 0,1,2 \rangle & \text{dice} \\ \langle 0,1,3 \rangle & \text{elephant} \\ \hline \langle 1,0,0 \rangle & \text{frog} \\ \langle 1,0,1 \rangle & \text{goat} \\ \langle 1,0,2 \rangle & \text{hat} \\ \langle 1,0,3 \rangle & \text{igloo} \\ \langle 1,1,0 \rangle & \text{jellyfish} \\ \langle 1,1,1 \rangle & \text{kite} \\ \langle 1,1,2 \rangle & \text{ladybug} \\ \langle 1,1,3 \rangle & \text{mermaid} \\ \langle 1,2,0 \rangle & \text{nose} \\ \langle 1,2,1 \rangle & \text{octopus} \\ \langle 1,2,2 \rangle & \text{piano} \\ \langle 1,2,3 \rangle & \text{queen} \\ \langle 1,3,0 \rangle & \text{rainbow} \\ \langle 1,3,1 \rangle & \text{shoe} \\ \langle 1,3,2 \rangle & \text{trombone} \\ \langle 1,3,3 \rangle & \text{umbrella} \\ \end{array} $$

We can stop there, because everything after !!\langle 1,3,3 \rangle!! begins with a !!2!! or a !!3!!, and so is some other triple in disguise. For example what sticker goes with !!\langle 0,2,3 \rangle!!? That's actually !!\langle 0,1,2 \rangle!! in disguise, it's !!2·\langle 0,1,2 \rangle!!, which is “dice”. Okay, how about !!\langle 3,3,1 \rangle!!? That's the same as !!3\cdot\langle 1,1,2 \rangle!!, which is “ladybug”. There are !!21!!, as we wanted. Note that the !!21!! naturally breaks down as !!1+4+4^2!!, depending on how many zeroes are at the beginning; that's where that comes from.

Now, just like before, to make a card, we pick two triples that have not yet gone together, say !!\langle 0,0,1 \rangle!! and !!\langle 0,1,0 \rangle!!. We start adding these together as before, obtaining !!\langle 0,1,1 \rangle!!. But we must also add together the disguised versions of these triples, !!\langle 0,0,2 \rangle!! and !!\langle 0,0,3 \rangle!! for the first, and !!\langle 0,2,0 \rangle!! and !! \langle 0,3,0 \rangle!! for the second. This gets us two additional sums, !!\langle 0,2,3 \rangle!!, which is !!\langle 0,1,2 \rangle!! in disguise, and !!\langle 0,3,2 \rangle!!, which is !!\langle 0,1,3 \rangle!! in disguise.

It might seem like it also gets us !!\langle 0,2,2 \rangle!! and !!\langle 0,3,3 \rangle!!, but these are just !!\langle 0,1,1 \rangle!! again, in disguise. Since there are three disguises for !!\langle 0,0,1 \rangle!! and three for !!\langle 0,1,0 \rangle!!, we have nine possible sums, but it turns out that the nine sums are only three different triples, each in three different disguises. So our nine sums get us three additional triples, and, including the two we started with, that makes five, which is exactly how many we need for the first card. The first card gets the stickers for triples !!\langle 0,0,1 \rangle, \langle 0,1,0 \rangle \langle 0,1,1 \rangle \langle 0,1,2 \rangle,!! and !!\langle 0,1,3 \rangle,!! which are apple, bicycle, carrot, dice, and elephant.

That was anticlimactic. Let's do one more. We don't have a card yet with ladybug and trombone. These are !!\langle 1,1,2 \rangle!! and !!\langle 1,3,2 \rangle!!, and we must add them together, and also the disguised versions:

$$\begin{array}{c|ccc} & \langle 1,1,2 \rangle & \langle 2,2,3 \rangle & \langle 3,3,1 \rangle \\ \hline \langle 1,3,2 \rangle & \langle 0,2,0 \rangle & \langle 3,1,1 \rangle & \langle 2,0,3 \rangle \\ \langle 2,1,3 \rangle & \langle 3,0,1 \rangle & \langle 0,3,0 \rangle & \langle 1,2,2 \rangle \\ \langle 3,2,1 \rangle & \langle 2,3,3 \rangle & \langle 1,0,2 \rangle & \langle 0,1,0 \rangle \\ \end{array}$$

These nine results do indeed pick out three triples in three disguises each, and it's easy to select the three of these that are canonical: they have a 1 in the leftmost nonzero position, so the three sums are !!\langle 0,1,0 \rangle,!! !!\langle 1,0,2 \rangle,!! and !!\langle 1,2,2 \rangle!!, which are bicycle, hat, and piano. So the one card that has a ladybug and a trombone also has a bicycle, a hat, and a piano, which should not seem obvious. Note that this card does have the required single overlap with the other card we constructed: both have bicycles.

Well, that was fun. Katara did hers with colored dots instead of stickers:

Katara's set of 21 cards.  Each
has five colored dots of 21 total different colors, and each colored
dot is labeled with a letter of the alphabet in the same color.  There
are some mistakes that are crossed out and corrected, and a couple of
mistakes that are not yet crossed out or corrected.

The ABCDE card is in the upper left; the bicycle-hat-ladybug-piano-trombone one is the second row from the bottom, second column from the left. The colors look bad in this picture; the light is too yellow and so all the blues and purples look black.

After I took this picture, we checked these cards and found a couple of calculation errors, which we corrected. A correct set of cards is:

$$ \begin{array}{ccc} \text{abcde} & \text{bhlpt} & \text{dgmpr} \\ \text{afghi} & \text{bimqu} & \text{dhjou} \\ \text{ajklm} & \text{cfkpu} & \text{diknt} \\ \text{anopq} & \text{cgjqt} & \text{efmot} \\ \text{arstu} & \text{chmns} & \text{eglnu} \\ \text{bfjnr} & \text{cilor} & \text{ehkqr} \\ \text{bgkos} & \text{dflqs} & \text{eijps} \\ \end{array} $$

Fun facts about finite projective planes:

  • This construction always turns a finite field of order !!n!! into a finite projective plane of order !!n!!.

  • A finite field of order !!n!! exists exactly when !!n!! is a prime power and then there is exactly one finite field. So this construction gives us finite projective planes of orders !!1,2,3,4,5,7,8,9,11,13,16!!, but not of orders !!6,10,12,14,15!!. Do finite projective planes of those latter orders exist?

  • Is this method the only way to construct a finite projective plane? Yes, when !!n<9!!. But there are four non-isomorphic projective planes of order !!9!!, and this only constructs one of them.

    What about for !!n≥11!!? Nobody knows.


[Other articles in category /math] permanent link